Which State's Exemptions Apply? The 730-Day Domicile Rule and Entireties Property in PA Bankruptcy
Reviewed by Sean P. Quinlan, Attorney
Short answer: Before comparing exemption lists, a Pennsylvania filer has to answer a threshold question: whose state law applies? Under 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3)(A), it is generally the law of the place where you were domiciled for the 730 days before filing, not simply where you live today. Pennsylvania has not opted out of the federal exemptions, so a debtor whose domicile points to Pennsylvania generally chooses between the federal list and the state-side list, and a married couple’s title to the home (tenancy by the entirety) can change the analysis. An attorney can confirm how these rules apply to your case.
Federal dollar amounts are deliberately left out here; they are adjusted periodically, so check the statute and the court’s current forms. For the lists themselves, see the Pennsylvania bankruptcy exemptions page. This page is about the rules that decide which system and which state’s law you get.
Step 1: The election between paragraph (2) and paragraph (3)
The statute itself requires a choice: the debtor may exempt property listed in “either paragraph (2) or, in the alternative, paragraph (3)” of section 522(b), 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(1). Paragraph (2) is the federal list, “property that is specified under subsection (d),” unless the applicable state law “specifically does not so authorize” (an “opt-out”). Paragraph (3) covers exemptions under state or local law, federal exemptions other than § 522(d), and two special categories discussed below.
Pennsylvania is not an opt-out state. The Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania has written that “Pennsylvania, however, has not opted out of the federal exemptions and thus either the state or federal exemption are available to its debtors.” In re Segen, No. 10-14574 (Bankr. E.D. Pa. Nov. 3, 2010). Because opt-out status varies by state, the next step matters.
Step 2: Whose state law applies? The 730-day domicile rule
Under § 522(b)(3)(A), the applicable state law is that of “the place in which the debtor’s domicile has been located for the 730 days immediately preceding” the filing. If the domicile was not in a single state for that whole period, the statute looks to the place where the domicile was located for the 180 days before the 730-day period, “or for a longer portion of such 180-day period than in any other place.”
Two Middle District of Pennsylvania decisions show how it plays out. In In re Brooks, No. 1-07-bk-03922 (Bankr. M.D. Pa. July 29, 2008), debtors who had not lived in Pennsylvania for the full 730 days had to look to Maryland law, and Maryland, unlike Pennsylvania, had opted out of the federal list. In In re Porvaznik, No. 5-11-bk-00390 (Bankr. M.D. Pa. Aug. 10, 2011), the debtor had lived in Louisiana, an opt-out state, but the court found her domicile had stayed in Pennsylvania, so the federal list was available. Whether domicile changed is a fact question.
The statute also contains a safety valve: if the domiciliary requirement “is to render the debtor ineligible for any exemption,” the debtor “may elect to exempt property that is specified under subsection (d).” Whether that applies is a question for an attorney.
Step 3: What each side looks like in Pennsylvania
The Pennsylvania state side
The state-side exemptions in Pennsylvania include, among others, 42 Pa.C.S. §§ 8123, 8124 and 8127. As currently posted by the General Assembly, § 8123(a) exempts property of the judgment debtor “to the value of $300” from attachment or execution on a judgment. Section 8124 lists specific categories (goods, retirement funds and accounts, insurance proceeds), and § 8127 is titled “Personal earnings exempt from process.”
On retirement funds, Pennsylvania’s § 8124(b)(1)(ix) does not protect amounts contributed within one year before filing (directly rolled-over funds are not excluded) or contributions above $15,000 in a one-year period. Federal protection under § 522(b)(3)(C) and (d)(12) is separate and has no one-year rule, but recent large contributions can draw scrutiny, so tell your attorney before filing.
The federal side
The § 522(d) list includes a residence interest in § 522(d)(1), a general “wildcard” in § 522(d)(5), and the right to receive “a social security benefit, unemployment compensation, or a local public assistance benefit” in § 522(d)(10)(A). Dollar caps are adjusted periodically under 11 U.S.C. § 104.
Step 4: Joint filers and tenancy by the entirety
Married couples. Section 522(b)(1) bars one spouse in a jointly administered case from electing paragraph (2) while the other elects paragraph (3), and “if the parties cannot agree on the alternative to be elected, they shall be deemed to elect paragraph (2),” where permitted. Section 522(m) applies the section separately to each debtor in a joint case, subject to subsection (b).
Entireties property. Section 522(b)(3)(B) lets a debtor exempt “any interest in property in which the debtor had, immediately before the commencement of the case, an interest as a tenant by the entirety or joint tenant” to the extent exempt from process under applicable nonbankruptcy law. In Pennsylvania the key limit is joint creditors: “generally, only joint claims against both a husband and wife attach to entireties property.” In re Allan, No. 5-08-bk-52478 (Bankr. M.D. Pa. July 20, 2010) (citing Napotnik v. Equibank, 679 F.2d 316 (3d Cir. 1982)). There, a judgment lien held by a creditor of only one spouse was avoided as impairing the entireties exemption.
The Third Circuit addressed entireties property under the federal list in In re Brannon, 476 F.3d 170 (3d Cir. 2007), and Segen applied it where only one spouse filed, holding the debtor may exempt entireties property under the federal exemptions. The entireties exemption in § 522(b)(3)(B) is part of the paragraph (3) election; a debtor who elects the federal list instead protects entireties property only through federal exemptions such as the § 522(d)(5) wildcard, as in Brannon. Separately, the U.S. Supreme Court has held that a federal tax lien can attach to a spouse’s interest in entireties property even when only that spouse owes the tax. United States v. Craft, 535 U.S. 274 (2002). Title, joint debts and tax debts all matter here, so this is not a do-it-yourself question.
Common fears and misconceptions
- “I can pick the best item from each list.” The statute provides for one paragraph or the other.
- “Where I live now decides it.” Domicile history under § 522(b)(3)(A) can control.
- “Exempt means my loan is gone.” Exemptions protect your interest in property from the estate; a lender’s lien is separate. See the car exemption article and the truck and equipment page.
- “Only Chapter 7 uses exemptions.” They matter in both; see Chapter 7, Chapter 13 and how they compare.
Mistakes to avoid before filing
- Moving to or from Pennsylvania without learning how the 730-day rule treats the move.
- Making a large retirement contribution shortly before filing.
- Re-titling a home, changing a deed, or transferring property to relatives before talking to an attorney.
- Assuming spouses can each take a different system.
- Estimating equity from a hopeful number rather than a realistic value.
What to expect at the consultation
Expect questions about every address where you have lived in roughly the last two to three years, how you hold title to real estate, who is on each debt, and what you own and owe on it. See how to file in Pennsylvania and the means test page for eligibility. Local pages include Dauphin County and Cumberland County.
Call (717) 724-7503 or schedule a consultation to talk through your situation.
We are a debt relief agency. We help people file for bankruptcy relief under the Bankruptcy Code.
Sean P. Quinlan, Esq., Quinlan Law Group, Camp Hill and Harrisburg, Pennsylvania.
This page is general information about Pennsylvania and federal bankruptcy law, not legal advice for your situation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. This is attorney advertising. Deadlines and outcomes depend on your facts; talk to a licensed attorney before relying on anything here.
Frequently asked questions
- Has Pennsylvania opted out of the federal bankruptcy exemptions?
- No. The Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania has written that Pennsylvania has not opted out under 11 U.S.C. 522(b)(2), so a debtor whose domicile points to Pennsylvania generally chooses between the federal list in 522(d) and the state-side exemptions in 522(b)(3).
- Can I use some Pennsylvania exemptions and some federal ones?
- The statute provides that the debtor may exempt property listed in either paragraph (2) or, in the alternative, paragraph (3) of section 522(b). Some federal non-bankruptcy exemptions are part of paragraph (3). An attorney can confirm how this applies to your case.
- What is the 730-day rule?
- Under 11 U.S.C. 522(b)(3)(A), the state exemption law that applies is that of the place where your domicile was located for the 730 days before filing, with a 180-day fallback if you moved during that period. A recent move can change which state's exemptions apply, and whether domicile changed is a fact question.
- Do spouses filing together have to use the same system?
- Section 522(b)(1) bars one spouse in a joint case from electing paragraph (2) while the other elects paragraph (3), and if they cannot agree they are deemed to elect paragraph (2) where permitted. Each spouse is treated separately under 522(m), subject to 522(b).
- How does tenancy by the entirety fit in?
- Section 522(b)(3)(B) lets a debtor exempt an entireties interest to the extent it is exempt from process under nonbankruptcy law. In Pennsylvania, joint creditors can reach entireties property, so who owes each debt matters. A debtor who elects the federal list instead protects entireties property only through federal exemptions. Get advice on your deed and debts.
- Where can I find the exemption dollar amounts?
- The federal amounts in 522(d) are adjusted periodically under 11 U.S.C. 104; check the statute and current court forms, or see the Pennsylvania exemptions page. Pennsylvania's own provisions are in 42 Pa.C.S. 8123, 8124 and 8127.